New Holiday Puzzles

Shop Now Shop This Puzzle
Patronus Practice Image 3 Patronus Practice Image 3
Last Chance To Buy

50% Off Harry Potter™

Shop Now
Costume Ball Image 3
Spooky Puzzles

Halloween Is Here

Shop NOw

Shop By Piece Count

100 Piece Mini 300 Pieces 500 Pieces 750 Pieces 1000 Pieces 1500 Pieces
The Gift That Arrives All Year

Passionate Puzzlers Club

Shop Now
The Easiest Holiday Gift

New York Puzzle Company Gift Cards

Shop Now
Up to
50% off
Harry Potter
Book Cover Collage Image 1
Quidditch Image 1

Advent Calendars

SHOP NOW

Passionate Puzzler's Club

LEARN MORE

Halloween Is Here

SHOP NOW

New Puzzle Arrivals

View all
New Arrival
After the Comeback Image 1
After the Comeback
500 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$27.00
New Arrivals
#fallstyle Image 1
#fallstyle
1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$29.00
New Arrivals
Cannonball Image 1
Cannonball
300 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$27.00
New Arrivals
Old Haunts Image 1
Old Haunts
1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$29.00
New Arrivals
Cat Mini Puzzle Collector's Set Image 1
Cat Mini Puzzle Collector's Set
Set of 6 Mini Puzzles
$65.00
New Arrivals
Book Club Image 1
Book Club
750 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$28.00
New Arrivals
Market Town Image 1
Market Town
1500 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$36.00
New Arrivals
Home for the Holidays Mini Image 1
Home for the Holidays Mini
100 Piece Mini Puzzle
$15.00
View all

Quality Mugs

View all
You're Wonderful Mug Image 1
You're Wonderful Mug
15oz Mug
$18.00
Outside the Box Mug Image 1
Outside the Box Mug
15oz Mug
$18.00
Pasta Cartoons Mug Image 1
Pasta Cartoons Mug
15oz Mug
$18.00
Alice Meets Dorothy Mug Image 1
Alice Meets Dorothy Mug
15oz Mug
$18.00
Sold Out
Mushrooms Mug Image 1
Mushrooms Mug
15oz Mug
$18.00

Shop By Collection

The New Yorker Magazine
New Yorker Magazine
Harry Potter™ Puzzles & Gifts
Harry Potter
Cornell Lab of Ornithology
Cornell Lab of Ornithology
MTA Transit Poster Puzzles
MTA Transit
Vintage Images
Vintage Images
Vogue Magazine Puzzle
Vogue Magazine

Shop by Artist

Loré Pemberton
Loré Pemberton
Janet Hill
Janet Hill
Adelina Lirius
Adelina Lirius
At the Strand Image 1
Jenny Kroik
Victo Ngai
Victo Ngai
Bill Mayer Puzzles
Bill Mayer

The Best Puzzles Ever

View all
Last Chance
Book Cover Collage Image 1
Book Cover Collage
500 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$27.00 $13.50 Save 50%
Baby It's Cold Outside Image 1
Baby It's Cold Outside
1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$29.00
Main Street Image 1
Main Street
1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$29.00
Bodega Cat Image 1
Bodega Cat
1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$29.00
Skating in the Park Image 1
Skating in the Park
750 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$28.00

Free Shipping

Enjoy free shipping on all orders over $75 within the US! Shop now and take advantage of this offer.

Giving Back

We pledge 1% of the sale of each puzzle to environmental non-profits committed to creating a healthy planet.

Piece-by-Piece

Earn points for every purchase and save! Get 40 Piece by Piece points simply by creating an account.